All About Reading vs Logic of English

Two of the best phonics-based reading programs on the market, but with very different philosophies. All About Reading uses multi-sensory Orton-Gillingham techniques. Logic of English teaches the rules behind English spelling. Here's how to pick.

Ease of Use Winner: All About Reading

All About Reading is truly open-and-go. The lessons are scripted word-for-word, and you can teach a lesson with zero prep. Logic of English requires the parent to learn the phonogram and spelling rule system first, which takes real effort.

Depth Winner: Logic of English

Logic of English goes deeper into why English works the way it does. Kids don't just learn to read — they understand the rules behind spelling and pronunciation. AAR teaches reading effectively but doesn't explain the underlying logic as thoroughly.

Struggling Readers Winner: All About Reading

For kids with dyslexia or significant reading struggles, AAR's multi-sensory Orton-Gillingham approach is specifically designed for them. The tactile letter tiles and careful progression make it the gold standard for struggling readers.

Spelling Integration Winner: Logic of English

Logic of English integrates reading, spelling, and handwriting into one program. AAR is reading-only — you need the separate All About Spelling program for spelling instruction. LoE is more efficient if you want everything in one.

Lesson Length Winner: All About Reading

AAR lessons run 15-20 minutes — perfect for young attention spans. Logic of English lessons often run 45-60 minutes, which is a lot for a 5 or 6-year-old. You can split LoE lessons, but it requires more planning.

Bottom Line

**Choose All About Reading** if you want a scripted, no-prep program that works especially well for struggling readers. It's easier to teach and gentler on young kids. **Choose Logic of English** if you want a deeper understanding of how English works and prefer to combine reading, spelling, and handwriting in one program. You can't go wrong with either — they're both among the best available.