Curriculum Comparisons

Head-to-head breakdowns of popular homeschool programs. No filler — just which one wins and why.

reading

All About Reading vs Logic of English

Two of the best phonics-based reading programs on the market, but with very different philosophies. All About Reading uses multi-sensory Orton-Gillingham techniques. Logic of English teaches the rules behind English spelling. Here's how to pick.

Read comparison
math

Both are from Art of Problem Solving and teach problem-solving over memorization. Beast Academy (elementary) is colorful and comic-based. AoPS (middle school) is serious and rigorous. Same philosophy, different intensity.

Read comparison
reading

Both teach phonics explicitly and systematically. Explode the Code is phonics-focused, colorful workbooks. Spalding integrates reading + writing + spelling in one system.

Read comparison
math

Two affordable, rigorous math programs — but they take different approaches. Mammoth is straightforward American curriculum. Singapore uses the bar model to teach conceptual understanding. Both work; it depends on your family.

Read comparison
math

Saxon Math vs Teaching Textbooks

Two of the most popular homeschool math programs, but they couldn't be more different. Saxon is the drill sergeant; Teaching Textbooks is the friendly tutor. Here's how to pick the right one for your kid.

Read comparison
history

Sonlight vs BookShark

The original vs the secular spin-off. BookShark was created by former Sonlight employees who wanted the same literature-based approach without the Christian worldview. Here's how they actually compare.

Read comparison